top of page

Fixed or Variable in 2026? How to Decide Without Guessing

Rachel Adams
Nov 10
3 min read

Every single week someone asks me whether they should go fixed or variable. And every week I give an answer that disappoints at least half of them, because the honest answer is that it depends far more on you than it does on the rate forecast.

I want to give you a way to make this decision that does not require either of us to know what the Bank of Canada will do next year.

Start by admitting nobody knows

The Bank of Canada meets eight times a year, and the overnight rate has been steady for a while now. Economists are split on what happens from here. They were also split a year ago, and two years ago, and a meaningful share of them were wrong each time.

I am not being cynical. I read the forecasts and they are useful for understanding risks. But if your mortgage decision requires a correct five-year prediction of monetary policy, you have built your decision on sand.

So set the forecast aside. Here is what to look at instead.

Question 1: What happens to your household if the payment goes up $300?

This is the question. Everything else is secondary.

If a $300 increase means you cancel a vacation and grumble about it, variable is genuinely an option for you. If a $300 increase means you are late on something, or you are moving money around at the end of every month to make it work, take the fixed rate. Pay for the certainty. That is what it is for.

I have watched clients ride out variable-rate increases without blinking, and I have watched others lose sleep over the same movement. The mortgage that is right on a spreadsheet and wrong for your nervous system is the wrong mortgage.

Question 2: How likely is it you'll break this mortgage early?

This one gets ignored constantly, and it is where the real money is.

Roughly six in ten Canadians break their mortgage before the end of a five-year term. Life happens — a job change, a separation, a growing family, a move, a chance to buy something better.

The penalty to break a variable mortgage is almost always three months' interest. Simple, predictable, usually a few thousand dollars.

The penalty to break a fixed mortgage at a big bank is the greater of three months' interest or something called the interest rate differential. The IRD, especially the way the big banks calculate it using posted rates, can run five figures. I have seen penalties north of $20,000 on ordinary suburban mortgages.

So if there is a real chance you sell or refinance mid-term, that fixed rate carries a cost that is not printed anywhere on your commitment letter.

Question 3: Is a shorter fixed term the actual answer?

This is the option people forget exists. It is not only fixed-for-five versus variable.

A three-year fixed often splits the difference nicely: you get payment certainty, but you are not married to the rate for half a decade, and the penalty exposure is smaller because there is less term left to calculate against.

I have put a lot of clients into three-year terms over the past couple of years, particularly people who want to sleep at night but also think rates might look different by the time their kid finishes high school.

What I actually ask clients

When someone sits down with me, we go through five things:

Your monthly cash-flow cushion, honestly assessed

How long you realistically expect to be in this property

Whether a lump-sum payment or a refinance is likely in the next few years

How you personally handle financial uncertainty — and yes, I ask directly

The actual spread between fixed and variable that week, which moves

Out of those five, only the last one is about rates. The other four are about you.

One thing I will say plainly

If you are stretching to qualify at all — if the approval is tight and the payment is at the top of what works — take the fixed rate. Do not take a variable because the starting payment is lower and you are hoping it goes lower still. That is not a strategy, it is a wish, and I have seen how it ends when it does not work out.

If you have room to breathe, equity in the property, and a stomach for movement, variable has historically done well over long periods. Historically. Not guaranteed.

Let's run your actual numbers

The right answer for your neighbour is often the wrong answer for you, which is why I will not give a blanket recommendation in a blog post.

What I will do is sit down with your numbers, show you both payments side by side, show you the penalty exposure on each, and let you decide with the whole picture in front of you. That conversation takes about half an hour. Book a time.

Comments


bottom of page